![]() |
||||
![]() |
Let's take a look at both designs. Overdrives
The primary drive includes the engine sprocket, clutch and primary chain. For a direct drive six-speed to function properly, the primary drive must be overdriven by installing a larger engine sprocket and longer chain. For example, big twin six-speed overdrive transmissions usually have an OD ratio of 0.80:1, 0.86:1 or 0.89:1, thereby reducing fifth-gear rpm between 20 percent and 11 percent. Although six-speed ODs are available in several different internal ratios, a 0.86:1 internal ratio, which decreases a standard transmission's fifth gear ratio (and engine rpm) by 14 percent, is a common choice. Here's another way of looking at it: Installing a 0.86:1 overdrive sixth gear in a trans with a 1:1 ratio/3.15:1 final drive results in fifth gear remaining with 1:1 and 3.15:1 ratios, but sixth gear becomes a 2.71:1 final drive ratio (3.15 x 0.86 = 2.71). By the way, I might add that overdrives are not limited to only six-speed transmissions. Five-speed transmissions can also have an overdrive gear where fourth gear is a 1:1 ratio and fifth gear uses a less than 1:1 overdrive ratio. Depending on the year and model of big twin, the engine is typically turning between 3000 and 3500 rpm at highway speeds. If we assume your engine is turning 3200 rpm at highway cruise with a five-speed 1:1 ratio nonoverdrive tranny, installing a 0.86:1 ratio overdrive reduces engine rpm by 14 percent, resulting in a reduction of 448 rpm or 2752 rpm at cruise speed. That is a significant reduction in rpm. It not only results in happier cruising and reduced vibration but also reduces engine wear while increasing fuel economy.
Six-Speed Transmissions
With a direct drive six-speed, high gear is not an overdrive gear. Instead, it has a 1:1 ratio like fifth gear has in a stock Harley five-speed transmission, and, of course, power exits directly through the drive gear. And since power is not flowing through two meshing gearsets, high gear noise and power losses are reduced while fuel mileage is increased. However, by using a 1:1 sixth gear, we have lost the benefit of the overdrive's rpm reduction in top gear. The dilemma is eliminated by overdriving the primary drive using a larger (more teeth) compensating sprocket on the engine. That results in a six-speed, which ratiowise is exactly like a six-speed overdrive transmission. The internal transmission ratios of first through fifth gears are also typically changed on a direct drive six-speed so that the first five gears retain the same overall ratios that they have in a stock five-speed but with a higher sixth gear, which is direct driven instead of overdriven.
Interestingly, the 2006 Dyna and 2007 and later big twin six-speed transmissions use a direct drive (called Cruise Drive) instead of an overdrive design. In contrast, the factory's complete six-speed transmission and six-speed gearsets sold for upgrading a 2006 and earlier five-speed transmission are a true overdrive and not direct drive. There are several additional benefits to a direct drive six-speed. First, direct drive six-speed transmissions typically have more evenly spaced gears than a stock five-speed, which eliminates wide gaps between gears while providing excellent power transfer and more even upshift points in the rpm band.
Another benefit is that unlike an overdrive six-speed, where the top gear robs power from the drivetrain, a direct drive's sixth gear is a power gear like the other five gears. So if you are into high performance, a direct drive six-speed is the way to go.
![]() Straight-cut vs. Helical-cut Gears Older big twin transmissions came supplied with only straight-cut gearsets. Starting with the 2006 Dyna and all 2007 and later big twins, both straight-cut and helical gear designs are used in big twin transmissions. Helical gears have an angled tooth pattern, which results in multiple teeth in mesh 100 percent of the time. This produces a higher contact ratio and reduces gear noise, but it also increases side loading while being slightly less efficient. JIMS offers six-speed overdrive gearsets for upgrading 2006 and earlier five-speed transmissions. Other Gearing Consideration. To get a taller high gear for less vibration and increased fuel mileage on long-distance interstate riding, you can raise your bike's final gearing by changing sprockets or pulleys on the transmission and rear wheel instead of installing an overdrive or direct drive six-speed. However, the problem with doing this is that all the lower gears would also be made taller. That would decrease acceleration and make cruising in hilly or mountainous terrain more difficult. On the other hand, a six-speed overdrive or direct drive transmission provides the best of both worlds, because it will add a taller gear for pleasant and efficient highway cruising while retaining crisp acceleration in the lower gears. Six-Speed Transmissions
Remember that many fuel-injected big twins have lower primary gearing (1.54:1 versus 1.44:1) than carbureted models, so choose accordingly. For high-torque big-inch engines, you may already have more low-speed torque than you really need, so a lower ratio first gear (lower numerically) may be in order. Additionally, a big motor can pull a taller sixth gear, so don't choose the overdrive sixth gear ratio (i.e., 0.89:1, 0.86:1 or 0.80:1) without first considering the displacement and power of your engine and highway riding style. For four-speed Shovelhead owners looking for an extra gear or two, Baker Drivetrain offers a six-into-four gearset. It is a six-speed overdrive with a 1:1 fifth gear and a 0.86:1 sixth gear. The OD sixth gear is good for a 500-rpm reduction in cruising rpm at highway speeds.
The S&S complete direct drive six-speed transmission features helical gears and is available in several different finishes. Remember that six-speed transmissions are available as complete transmissions or gearset kits. Of course, a complete transmission is more costly, but then again you have a used transmission to sell, which can offset some of the costs. Additionally, some aftermarket complete transmissions include upgraded features like improved shift mechanisms, offering smoother, more positive shift action and reduced component wear. Such features may be worth the additional costs. Installation Considerations
For wide-tire bikes, Baker Drivetrain and JIMS Machine offer right-side drive transmissions to eliminate the need for left-side transmission offsets. Final Thoughts
Calculating Drive Ratios
The calculations look as follows: 37 24 = 1.54:1 Primary Ratio 70 32 = 2.19:1 secondary ratio 1.54 x 2.19 = 3.37 final drive ratio Now, let's assume we install a six-speed overdrive with a 0.86:1 ratio to the above gearing combination. What would be the final drive ratio of the overdrive sixth gear?
3.37 x 0.86 = 2.90
overdrive sixth gear
final drive ratio
writer: D. William Denish
Return from Harley Six Speed to Harley Riders Guide
|
|||